Tourism-boosting rebuilding of historic buildings and urban form: the case study of Yanghe Tower and its urban morphology in Zhengding, China

January 2022
Historic city Public space Urban heritage Reconstruction
  • Qian Liu , First Author , Politecnico di Milano
  • Laura Pezzetti , Politecnico di Milano
Read Full-Text
Tourism-boosting rebuilding of historic buildings and urban form: the case study of Yanghe Tower and its urban morphology in Zhengding, China
Yanghe Tower in 1933, taken by Liang Sicheng

Abstract

Tourism has recently been viewed as an economic growth engine for Chinese small historic cities, including Zhengding in Northern China. However, the intensive tourism-boosting projects have far more impacts on these cities than merely economic development. Yanghe Tower was first built in Zhengding in the Tang Dynasty, renovated many times, and demolished in the 1960s, although it had been included in Liang- Sicheng’s surveys in 1933. The local government rebuilt the Tower in 2017 to make it a tourist attraction through an uncritical rebuilding that formed an urban unit with a texture and meaning that never existed in the city. The result is a standalone monument disjointed from its historic and morphological layering, which is crucial for the Tower’s urban role and memory narrative. This paper instead reads the primary element of Yanghe Tower in its historical evolution and its relationship with the overall urban form. By reading the mutual relationship between the Tower and the urban development in both permanence and modification, the paper brings evidence of the deep structure and meanings of urban form that should guide any strategy of intervention and reconstruction beyond musealization and commodification.

Keywords

Rebuilding; Yanghe Tower; Zhengding; Urban form; Tourism

Conference

This paper was presented orally at the XXVIII International Seminar on Urban Form (ISUF), themed “Urban Form and the Sustainable and Prosperous City”, held in Glasgow, UK, from June 29 to July 03, 2021.

Author contributions

  • Qian Liu conceptualised the research, collected materials, made the drawings and drafted the manuscript.
  • Laura Pezzetti drafted the manuscript, supervised the research and critically revised the manuscript.

Key figures

Map from Zhengding Gazetteer dated 1646, showing the urban axes and two symmetric square blocks

Map from Zhengding Gazetteer dated 1646, showing the urban axes and two symmetric square blocks

The ‘city for tourists’ and the ‘axes for tourists’, showing the remaining heritages sites in Zhengding

The ‘city for tourists’ and the ‘axes for tourists’, showing the remaining heritages sites in Zhengding